Andy Shay
Forst Family Head Coach of Men's Lacrosse · Yale
Coach Legacy updates once a year, after the NCAA championship. Last updated: June 2026.
Coach Legacy Score
- National championships × 1100
- Title games × 280
- Players drafted × 2266
- Career wins × 20250.5
- Final Fours × 250
- NCAA tournament wins × 936
- NCAA tournament appearances × 1030
- Conference tournament titles × 525
- Tewaaraton winners × 125
- Head-coaching seasons × 2323
- Conference regular-season titles × 416
- Win % points above .500 × 12.912.9
- Tewaaraton finalists × 16
How it's scored: the board explains the weights (a national title is 100, a Final Four 25, a Tewaaraton winner 25).
Key numbers
- Career W-L
- 202-119-1
- D1 head coach · .629
- NCAA appearances
- 10
- NCAA wins
- 9
- Final Fours
- 2
- Championships
- 1
- Conference titles
- 4 / 5
- regular season / tournament
- Tewaaraton
- 1 / 1
- winners / finalists
- All-Americans
- —
- USILA 1st / 2nd / 3rd
- Players Drafted
- 22 or more
Every number counts his Division I head-coaching jobs only. — is unknown (not found in the public pages read), never zero. A + means at least that many; * marks a record missing a D1 job or a season.
Career
- 202-119-1 (thru 2026)
Forst Family Head Coach of Men's Lacrosse · 2004–present
Division I head-coaching jobs, the ones Coach Legacy counts. Assistant and non-D1 jobs aren't listed.
Postseason by year
- 2026NCAA tournament
- 2023NCAA tournament
- 2022NCAA tournament · Conference regular-season title
- 2019NCAA title game
- 2018National champion · Conference regular-season title
- 2017NCAA tournament · Conference tournament title · Conference regular-season title
- 2016NCAA tournament · Conference tournament title
- 2015NCAA tournament · Conference tournament title
- 2013NCAA tournament · Conference tournament title
- 2012NCAA tournament · Conference tournament title
- 2010Conference regular-season title
The seasons the pages name. A bio's narrative may not name every season, so this list can be short of his totals above.
Tewaaraton Award
- winnerBen Reeves · Yale2018
- finalistMatt Brandau · Yale2024
Credited to the head coach of the player's school that season. Winners 2001–2026; finalists 2024–2026 only (older finalist lists aren't on the foundation's site).
All-Americans
— USILA's full lists couldn't be read yet, so no All-American is counted for any coach. What his school says is below.
Honors
- 2018 · USILA Division I Coach of the Year
- 2024 · Ivy League Coach of the Year
- 2026 · NEILA Coach of the Year
Sources
- https://yalebulldogs.com/sports/mens-lacrosse/coaches · name and title
- https://yalebulldogs.com/sports/mens-lacrosse/roster/coaches/andy-shay/1047 · career stops, division, record, career record, record at his school, conference tournament appearances, read for conference wins (not found), honors
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_NCAA_Division_I_lacrosse_programs · division
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yale_Bulldogs_men%27s_lacrosse · record, conference titles
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NCAA_Division_I_men%27s_lacrosse_tournament_appearances_by_school · NCAA appearances, NCAA wins, Final Fours
- https://dartmouthsports.com/sports/mens-lacrosse/roster/coaches/sean-kirwan/10563 · title games
- https://yalebulldogs.com/news/2018/5/28/5_28_2018_6856.aspx · championships
- https://www.tewaaraton.com/the-tewaaraton-award · Tewaaraton
- https://www.tewaaraton.com/post/2024-tewaaraton-finalists · Tewaaraton
Pages read on 2026-10-04, 2026-10-05, 2026-10-07 and 2026-10-08.